Wednesday, May 8, 2024

The Rise and Fall of the Dubuque Brewing and Malting Building

                                          The Rise and Fall of the

Dubuque Brewing and Malting Building

(by Paul Hemmer – April 2024)

 Dubuque’s brewing history extends back to 1846 when Anton Gehrig and Anton Heeb began construction HEEB BREWING COMPANY on Couler Avenue (now Central). In 1855 Mathias Tschirgi and J. Schwind established THE WESTERN BREWERY, followed soon after when Titus Schmidt, B. Scherr and F. Beck opened THE IOWA BREWERY which became Schmidt Beer. Adam Glab opened THE NORTHERN BREWERY in 1865.

                             
            DUBUQUE BREWING AND MALTING was created in 1892 as a joint venture of these four. At the time it was regarded as a way to increase prices and rumors persisted that several of the breweries would close. Officers and directors of the new venture denied the allegations, stating that their goal was to increase the capacity of all the breweries, and to brew the best product at fair prices. That promise proved true. The four continued operation in their own plants with a main office located at 2127 Couler- now the northeast corner at Central and 22nd Street.



            In 1894 the group announced plans to construct a large new facility to be the combined home for their joint enterprise. Again, the general public met the concept with skepticism because the entire nation was in an economic depression known as The Panic of 1893 which deeply affected every sector of the economy and produced political upheaval that led to the presidency of William McKinley.

            The new firm selected a ten-acre site at 30th & Jackson for the construction of a massive new brewery. Louis Lehle from Chicago, an experienced designer and builder of modern breweries was engaged to draw the plans. Then, the local architecture firm Fridolin Heer & Son were hired to design the facility. Heer’s other significant local structures included Dubuque First Presbyterian Church, the chapel of St. Raphael’s Cathedral, Sacred Heart Church, St. Francis Convent, and later the Dubuque County Court House and many fine Dubuque homes.

 

            The Sunday, August 4, 1995 Dubuque Herald provides as detailed description of the massive building.

         “The time when Dubuque will be known and noted as the brewing center of the great northwest territory is not far distant. Within six months the Dubuque Malting company's new brewery will be completed and in operation. It will be the largest and costliest north of St. Louis and west of the Mississippi. In construction and modern appliances, methods, and machinery it will not have a superior.”

         “For 220 feet along Jackson Street and back an equal depth on Twenty-Seventh Street the great structure towers five stories in the air. Three stories are yet to be added. The lot extends back 550 feet to the right-of-way of the Chicago Great Western Railway company. This great space, comprising almost three acres, is, with the exception of a court 100 x 95 in the center, covered with great buildings.”

         “The foundation was no trivial affair, in fact it gave an indication of what a magnificent lasting structure the brewery was to be. The On beds of concrete, down twelve feet. it was laid twelve feet wide at the bottom. and composed of large stones overlapping each other, making it utterly impossible for any part of the massive buildings to settle the fraction of an inch.”

“89,000 cubic feet of stone were used in the foundation, 25,000 feet of concrete under the foundation, and 3,500,000 brick, 5,000 feet of cut stone, 6,000 feet of sewerage for draining both buildings and yards, and 800 tons of iron (exclusive of the iron to be used in stairways) will be used in the erection of the buildings, and the floor space will amount to 224,570 feet or five and one-half acres.”

        “The brewery plant will consist of the office building, stock, brew, mill, boiler and machinery houses, bottling works, barn. wagon sheds, etc.

         There will be two main buildings, fronting on Jackson street—one consisting of the office building and stock house, the other of the mill, brew and machinery houses. Back of them will be the other buildings. These two main buildings are separated by a roadway thirty feet wide leading into the court spoken of above. The entire first story on Jackson Street including the arch over the roadway is of cut Bedford limestone. The remainder of the structures are of pressed brick.”

         “The office building occupies the southwest corner of the plant. Five stories with all the interior iron construction are completed. This building will be seven stories high and will be surmounted by two towers, which will extend thirty feet above the building. The building has a frontage of 62 feet and is forty feet deep.” 

         “The building will have galvanized iron cornices and a slate roof in which respect it will differ from the other buildings, whose roofs will be of gravel. The first floor will contain the general and private offices, lobby, vault. dress rooms and toilet. room. The offices will be fitted up in hand-some style. The main entrance will be in the middle of the building, on Jackson Street. In the second floor will be located the meeting room, vault, superintendents office, toilet rooms. etc. The third floor will contain a billiard room and the north part condensing tubs.”

         “On the fourth floor will be located a Baudlet cooler. open condensers and beer pumps; on the fifth floor, beer tanks and a Baudlet cooler. In the sixth and seventh stories will be located water tanks.”

         “The stock house adjoins and is cast of the office building. It is five stories in height and is now under roof and ready for workmen to begin putting in floors. The first story will be devoted to shaving casks and to the cellar. the second to stock or settling tubs. The third will be used for fermenting tubs and the fourth will be given to settling tubs and the fifth will be the shaving floor. There will be three cold storage rooms, chip casks ‘with a capacity of 150 barrels each. and each stock tub will hold 25 barrels.”

“The Machinery House is located immediately across the driveway from the office building. It is 50 feet 6 inches by 50 feet, five stories, and is now under roof. The first and second floors will be used for machinery rooms, the third for the machine shop, the fourth for hop storage, and the fifth as as having room. The machinery room on the first floor will accommodate three ice making machines with a capacity of 100 tons per day each, which is double the amount that will be required for the contemplated capacity. The building will also contain a large engine to drive the machinery in this and the brew house building adjoining it. It will also contain the pumps and the electric light plant.”

         “The Brew House is four stories high and under roof. It is 54x52 feet.It will contain ample room for two complete brewing outfits. The steam kettles are to be of copper and will have each a capacity of 375 barrels. The mash tubs are to be of steel and will be seventeen feet in diameter and provided with patent raising and lowering mashing machine and grain remover. All other tubs and cookers in the brew house will be of steel, and will be fitted up with all the modern improvements and the best machinery. All floors in the brew house will be aid in rock asphalt on top of steel beams. An open light court in the center will extend from the ground floor to the top floor and will receive its light from a skylight. A driveway leads in from Jackson Street for convenience in loading and unloading.”

“The Malt House occupies the northwest corner of the plant. It will be eight stories in height, and will be surmounted by a symmetrical tower. Six stories of this building are now up. It will contain four malt bins with a storage capacity of 20,000 bushels. Above the malt bins will be a malt cleaner and a non-explosive malt mill. All of the machinery used in the mill house to elevate and convey the malt and meal will be of the latest improved pattern.”

         “Two lines of street cars furnish easy communication with the city. One line passes the building. the other is away a block distant. Then the near proximity of the railroad affords every convenience for shipping.”

            The Grand Opening celebration was held on May 8, 1896. Newspaper accounts claim 15, 000 attended. The reception lasted from 3 to 9 pm but by noon the street and sidewalk in front of the main entrance were massed with people seeking admittance. Among the prominent speakers was Mathias Tschirgi brewmaster of Dubuque’s original “Western Brewery.”

             In his address, Dubuque’s Mayor Duffy proudly boasted that “Every dollar of over $600,000 here invested comes from Dubuque. Every man employed in building it lives in Dubuque. Every stockholder in the company was born and raised in Dubuque. Their children have grown up with Dubuque. Their homes are in Dubuque. The history and growth of their business is a part of the history of Dubuque As Dubuquers we are proud of of this great institution. But the stockholders are proud of it for other reasons. It is the monument of which they have labored.”

            Dr. Heynisch, President of The Brewers Academy of Chicago delivered his address in German - reciting the history of the manufacture of beer from the early days to the present. Then in English he added - “Beer has become the great American beverage. They tell me that no house in Dubuque is considered properly equipped unless it has a case of Dubuque Malting Company beer in the cellar. It is the best made.

Visitors entered through the main office, and passed through the private offices which were profusely and elaborately decorated with magnificent bouquets and potted palms and plants. On the second floor everyone received a handsome souvenir. Then guides conducted the guests through the great plant. In the building at the east side of the court Cthe refreshment stands where food and brew were served to everyone.

Music was provided during the day in the refreshment area by the Dubuque Juvenile Band directed by Professor Rastatter. The Original Italian Orchestra performed in the souvenir area.]

The plant was promoted as the most modern brewing and malting facility in the country with a capacity of of 300,000 barrels. “The beer is made with the utmost care as to sanitary conditions and materials. The artesian water is secured from deep wells.”

 “Hops are imported from Bavaria at a great expense merely because they are better than American hops, and barley is brought a great distance to secure the best. It is this care which has made the Dubuque Brewing & Malting Companies Banquet, Export, and Muenchener beers known throughout the west and Vimalt Health Tonic known in every state of the union.”

 Of all the beers produced Banquet was the most popular.

    

The February 28,1910 Telegraph-Herald reported that in addition to wagons drawn by a stable of 80 horses, “big electric trucks” operated in Dubuque for city delivery.” These trucks operated with a 20 horsepower motor powered by 110-volt storage batteries and could carry a 10,000-pound load at 6 miles per hour on the level and take a 10 percent grade with full power.

 “The Dubuque Brewing & Malting is the largest manufacturing institution in Iowa and one of the very largest in the northwest. Outside of Milwaukee and St. Louis, there is no brewery in the west that can compare in size and not even there in completeness. 200 people are employed and to keep up to the demand, the business operates 24 hours a day.

The death ell tolled for Dubuque Brewing and Malting when early in 1915 the Iowa Legislature enacted a law that “prohibits the manufacture for sale or keeping for sale intoxicating liquors, and the transportation of same within the state."  It would become effective January 1, 1916.

 Officials estimated that this Prohibition would cost Dubuque the loss of approximately $69,000 in taxes for “municipal upkeep - fire and police protection, street lighting and cleaning, park maintenance and improvement, etc. Critics of the law it would mean the 58 vacant store buildings, the loss of employment at Brunswick-Balke-Collender (manufacturers of bar equipment) and the loss of at least 200 jobs at Dubuque Brewing and Malting and the other breweries operating in the city.

 Adding further to the dubious positive result of this law, most everyone agreed that “It is doubtful if prohibition will materially reduce the amount of alcoholic beverages used in the city.”

 On December 28, 1895 the Telegraph-Herald reported – “Although Iowa will become dry as the desert of Sahara after midnight Friday, one more party will be held next Monday or Tuesday. But it isn’t going to be one of those rollicking parties of the palmy days. Instead, it is going to be presided over by strict agents of Uncle Sam’s revenue department, and the beer, rather than being poured down thirsty throats, will pour into the sewer. It will represent the “stock” left after the prohibition nut is screwed down and may amount to more than 300 barrels. The party is being held at the Dubuque Brewing and Malting Company building. No invitations will be sent.”

 President A.A. Heeb stated that the brewing equipment had been shut down since September, but brisk holiday business had successfully drained the stock except for about 300 barrels. Thirty Five horses had been sold and the remaining 50 were to be shipped out before years end. The heavy machinery was sold to brewers in states that remained “wet” and all empty barrels, wagons and trucks were gone.

"My associates and mvself will be through when the prohibitory law has become effective.We are not going to start up elsewhere as reported. The law has been made and all the liquor interests have to do is abide by it. It is too late now to make a fight. The 100 men remaining, including those who worked on the outside, will be thrown out of work.”

                 The beautiful building sat unused until 1917 when a local meat packing firm incorporated as Corn Belt Packing Company. That business lasted until 1924 and then supposedly remained unused.

Then on the evening of June 24, 1929 after receiving numerous tips on suspicious activity, Federal Agents raided a portion of the two upper floors to discover a very profitable manufacturing facility turning out 350 gallons of alcohol every day. Four agents forced their way into the building through a series of heavily protected doors. More than 1,000 gallons of 180-proof alcohol was found plus 40,000 gallons of mash, 225 pounds of yeast, 5,000 empty gallon cans, a 3,000-gallon cooker, a quality of egg crates used to ship out the produce, and more additional equipment. Although ownership of the still was not identified, the presumption was that it was part of Al Capone’s operations in the Dubuque area.

 

The building saw new legitimate life in 1933 when the brewery was purchased by a syndicate of Milwaukee investors known as the Wisconsin Trades Corporation. It was renamed The Julien Dubuque Brewing Company. The plan was to open in January 1934 with product at market by April. It never happened.

The Dubuque’s Chamber of Commerce in 1937 thought they had secured a new tenant – U. S. Sugar and Syrup Refineries Inc. When officials came to Dubuque in 1938, they abandoned their plans.

A partnership of Urban Haas and Cyril Wissel (H & W MOTOR EXPRESS) and Harry Wahlert (DUBUQUE PACKING COMPANY) purchased the building in 1942 for $10,000. The trucking firm used a portion of the building as their home office and DUBUQUE PACKING COMPANY used several floors for ham storage.

            In 1977 the structure was recommended for placement on the NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES, but the owners protested, claiming the designation might restrict them from “improving the property for use to best advantage.”

           A local preservationist group in November of 2005 led by restoration developer John Gronen, waged a battle to again save the building from demolition. According to Jack Felderman of Continental Realty, a group of investors had submitted an offer to purchase most of the seven-story structure and adjoining outbuildings to tear it down for its steel and brick. Although the city’s Historic Preservation Committee had already signed off on an attempt to save the building, the City Council took up the issue at the November 21st meeting. The vote was 6-1 to place the building a conservation district. Eventualy the 30th street section was sold of Auto & Truck Parts, Inc and the H&W section to 3M Development.

            By the fall of 2008, the city considered but failed to include the building in a new urban renewal district.  Two years later it became subject to the city’s Demolition by Neglect ordinance. The owners asked Dubuque Main Street to help find grants and funding sources

            In 2016 building owner Jim Krueger was cited for failing to have the building inspected by a structural engineer. Court documents stated that the building posed a "threat of imminent danger to the general public and surrounding property owners." Heavy rains caused part of the roof to collapsed and was proclaimed “beyond salvage.” Then Krueger announced that he had arranged an outside buyer for the property who would invest up to $30 million to convert it into an apartment complex.

            Another announcement was made on March 21, 2017 that the landmark building had been sold to Steve Emerson, a developer from Cedar Rapids for $865,000. He planned a $20 million renovation project, and was pursuing a federal redevelopment grant, plus workforce housing and historic preservation tax credits which would determine how the project proceeded.

            In June 2018 the city council announced that it would hold a meeting on a proposal to provide $2.5 million in incentives to rehabilitate the building. That would be recovered through tax-increment revenue as the valuation of the building increased with improvements. The City also pledged a grant of $850,000 through the Downtown Housing Creation Program if at east seventy-five apartment units were constructed and $35,000 for facade, design and planning and financial consultant expenses.

             The development plan called for Emerson to create at least 110 apartments, not less than 17,500 square feet of commercial space, and at least 194 parking spaces for tenants. Then on April 13, 2019 high winds blew down a section of the complex and struck the sidewalk. Parts of Jackson and East 30th STREETS were closed for up to a week by debris and brick. Still, the owners continued to express hope that work on restoration could begin that summer.

         As he struggled to obtain funding, Emerson’s plans were modified to the development of 82 one- and two-bedroom and efficiency apartments above 17,000 square feet of office, commercial and retail space.

         On February 7, 2022, the members of the City Council voted to approve a resolution canceling the agreement for the restoration of the building because the developer had failed to meet project deadlines outlined in the original agreement and for failing to maintain the building which continued to deteriorate.

         Finally, on January 16, 2014, Steve Emerson called his decision to purchase the former Dubuque Brewing and Malting Company a 'very costly mistake.'

         As the walls come tumbling down in April of 2024, we reflect on the glory days, the folly of Prohibition, and the failed efforts to perverse this treasured landmark of Dubuque.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Rise and Fall of the Dubuque Brewing and Malting Building

                                           The Rise and Fall of the Dubuque Brewing and Malting Building (by Paul Hemmer – April 2024) ...